Regulatory Enforcement Approaches for Mass Population Displacement
Journal article, 2020

During the European Refugee Situation in 2015, Sweden received an influx of forcibly displaced persons seeking asylum, the highest number of asylum seekers per capita among European Union member states. A challenge existed in providing accommodations within the Swedish built environment, in contrast to other housing solutions such as geographically distinct refugee camps. Regulations are one method of maintaining consistent standards of buildings, but they are effective only if they are enforced. During uncertainty, compliance decisions can be based on cognitive understanding (cognitive legitimacy). Otherwise, deterrence-based regulation is rooted in direct consequences (pragmatic legitimacy), and responsive regulation relies on normative motivation (moral legitimacy) for compliance. This study explored the normative aspect of regulatory enforcement through inspections. In 2017, 34 semistructured interviews were conducted with individuals involved with providing temporary accommodations in Sweden during 2015-2016. From these, six interviews with employees of regulatory enforcement agencies were qualitatively analyzed to discover how regulators legitimized. Findings show that regulators justified their inspections predominantly based on what is considered as a socially acceptable approach (procedural legitimacy) and what is understandable based on their personal experience (comprehensibility legitimacy). This study provides practical insight to regulators regarding the benefits for using responsive regulation during institutional responses to mass population displacement in urban communities. Findings will assist in ensuring that the quality of buildings is consistent for the general population and reduces variation in the safety provided by buildings. Additionally, this analysis contributes to the literature addressing mass population displacement and provides new knowledge of organizational legitimacy in technical applications.

Deterrence

Enforcement

Building regulations

Refugee

Responsive

Legitimacy

Author

Miriam E. Hacker

University of Washington

Jessica Kaminsky

Eawag - Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology

Kasey M. Faust

The University of Texas at Austin

Sebastien Rauch

Chalmers, Architecture and Civil Engineering, Water Environment Technology

Journal of Construction Engineering and Management - ASCE

0733-9364 (ISSN)

Vol. 146 5 1820

Subject Categories

Civil Engineering

DOI

10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001820

More information

Latest update

4/21/2020