Forest biomass in the energy transition: Modelling industrial flexibility and inter-sectoral dependencies
Doctoral thesis, 2026
Assuming that fossil carbon is phased out and that the demand for biogenic carbon increases, the results show that the investments and operational strategies that become rational in the near future depend on policy and market developments in sectors outside the traditional forest industry. The main contribution of the pulp mill (beyond pulp) may, thereby, shift from base-load electricity to flexibility, and eventually to replacing fossil feedstocks through lignin extraction or bioenergy with carbon capture and utilisation (BECCU), or to negative emissions through bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS). For the individual mill, carbon capture becomes the most profitable option if negative emissions are priced high enough. At the system level, however, gasification plants producing renewable methanol, in which CO₂ is a by-product of the syngas, deliver negative emissions at a lower cost when there is also a demand for methanol. The outcome of a policy for negative emissions therefore depends on whether biogenic carbon is also in demand for fuels and chemicals.
As new demands are placed on forest biomass, the interplay between the forest biomass system and the wider energy system changes at both the mill and the system level. Flexible operation of processes and boilers in the pulp mill increases the value of the mill’s surplus electricity and reduces the cost of lignin extraction, which is dominated by the foregone electricity generation. BECCU, where captured CO₂ is combined with hydrogen generated by electrolysis, raises the product yield further, but at an even higher cost in electricity. At the system level, targets for methanol and negative emissions reallocate biomass away from combined heat and power (CHP) plants, whose electricity generation is lost, while the heat pumps that replace them in the heating sector increase further the electricity demand.
Under the studied conditions, the role of forest biomass shifts from that of a fuel supplying heat and electricity towards that of a source of carbon, whose refinement into products or more valuable energy carriers is paid for with heat and electricity. The value of the biomass then varies with time and location, depending on which alternative it replaces.
Industrial flexibility
Lignin extraction
Biofuels
Chemical pulp mill
Energy system modelling
Negative emissions
BECCU
Sector coupling
Biomass allocation
BECCS
Author
Simon Ingvarsson
Chalmers, Space, Earth and Environment, Energy Technology
The chemical pulp mill as a flexible prosumer of electricity
Energy Conversion and Management: X,;Vol. 20(2023)
Journal article
Lignin extraction in chemical pulp mills: The role of flexible operation
Sustainable Chemistry for the Environment,;Vol. 7(2024)
Journal article
Chemical pulp mills in future energy markets with variable electricity prices and increased demand for biogenic carbon
Biomass and Bioenergy,;Vol. 199(2025)
Journal article
Öberg, S., Ingvarsson, S., Odenberger, M., & Johnsson, F. Synergies and trade-offs for forest biomass use under joint BECCS and renewable methanol targets in Sweden
The energy transition challenges the existing use of forest biomass through new demands for transportation fuels, flexible electricity generation, and so-called negative emissions through bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS). This thesis examines which choices in the forest biomass system may become economically rational as external market and policy conditions develop in the coming decades, and how the interplay between the forest biomass system and the wider energy system thereby may change.
The results show that the investments and operational strategies that become rational depend on policy developments and market trends in sectors that have historically been separated from the forest industry. The most valuable contribution of the chemical pulp mill beyond pulp may shift over time, from supplying base-load electricity, to providing flexibility, and later to supplying biogenic carbon for fuels and chemicals or for BECCS.
The interplay with the wider energy system changes as the pulp mills shift their electricity generation in time and trade electricity for higher product yields – and as biomass is reallocated away from heat and power plants, whose heat supply is largely replaced by heat pumps. If the new demands grow strong enough, fuel production may eventually compete with the pulp mills for the pulpwood itself, raising the question of whether pulp and paper production remain competitive uses of the forest biomass.
Subject Categories (SSIF 2025)
Bioenergy
Energy Engineering
Energy Systems
Driving Forces
Sustainable development
Areas of Advance
Energy
DOI
10.63959/chalmers.dt/5956
ISBN
978-91-8103-499-8
Doktorsavhandlingar vid Chalmers tekniska högskola. Ny serie: 5956
Publisher
Chalmers
KA-salen, Kemigården 4
Opponent: Prof. Joakim Lundgren, Department of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics, Luleå University of Technology, Sweden.