Decision and Planning for Additive Manufacturing Implementation in the Early Design Phase
Doctoral thesis, 2026

Additive Manufacturing (AM) has been promoted for almost two decades. Although this family of technologies has found niche applications in several industries, such as aerospace and healthcare, its potential remains largely unexplored across many other sectors. Currently, less than 0.2% of the global manufacturing output is dedicated to various AM processes. This limited share is explained partly by technical limitations. It also relates to how the decision to use AM is generally made. The judgement of whether to implement AM or not tends to be reached once the concept and the geometry are already committed, usually based on individual experience. At that point few design features through which AM can create value are available. The decision to implement AM concerns both the product and the operation, including the product design, efficiency of the operation, and also the ecosystem around such operation. For instance, organisational competence, market accessibility and sustainability. The decision therefore concerns both the operation and the strategy viewpoints, which goes beyond the geometry analysis of a product. As this decision can be complicated, this thesis starts with covering the needs and barriers that shape such decision from both operational and strategic viewpoints. These findings are based on literature reviews, industrial case studies, interviews, workshops and controlled experiments. These needs and barriers are translated into concrete criteria which a decision support needs to entail. On this basis, Feasibility, Suitability and Viability (FSV) framework is introduced to give structure to such support based on the identified criteria. The framework makes the distinction between whether AM can be used and whether it should be from both operational and strategic perspectives. Two methods are introduced to operationalise the framework and meet the identified criteria of a decision support. Each method is implemented as a working prototype and was evaluated in controlled experiments involving academic and industrial participants. The evaluation demonstrated positive results in both methods in terms of usefulness and usability. It showed that the support changed what was
assessed and what was prioritised in the decision. It also identified where each method needs further development. The thesis extends the scope of Design for Additive Manufacturing (DfAM), from how to design for AM to also whether and when to use it.

Engineering Design

Decision Support

Design for AM

Additive Manufacturing

VDL
Opponent: Katja Holtta-Otto

Author

Tina Hajali

Chalmers, Industrial and Materials Science, Product Development

The Importance of Digitalisation in Industrialising Additive Manufacturing: Learnings from the DIDAM P2030 Project

Advances in Transdisciplinary Engineering,;Vol. 52(2024)p. 442-452

Paper in proceeding

Feasibility and suitability analysis of additive manufacturing in pre-conceptual design phase

Journal of Engineering Design,;Vol. 37(2026)p. 702-740

Journal article

An iterative investigation of needs and barriers in deciding when to design for additive manufacturing

Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering Design, ICED,;Vol. 6(2026)p. 1971-1980

Paper in proceeding

A risk analysis method for implementation of additive manufacturing

Journal of Engineering Design,;Vol. 37(2026)p. 311-338

Journal article

Hajali, T., Brahma, A., & Isaksson, O. (2026). Assessing risks and opportunities for additive manufacturing implementation [Manuscript in press]. Journal of Engineering Design.

Additive manufacturing (AM), commonly known as 3D printing, has been promoted for almost two decades as a process capable of producing customised and complex products. Despite these opportunities, it accounts for less than 0.2 percent of global manufacturing output. This limited share is partly explained by technical limitations, and partly by how the decision to use AM is made. The decision is typically reached late in the design process, once the geometry is defined, by assessing whether an existing part suits AM. By then, most of the capabilities AM offers are no longer available, which hinders its industrial implementation. The decision therefore needs to be made in the early design phase, when the part can still be designed around those capabilities. It also reaches beyond the product itself, as it involves the ecosystem around it, including the operation, the organisation, the market and sustainability.

In this thesis, how this decision, whether and when to use AM, can be supported in the early design phase is investigated. The needs and barriers that shape the decision from both operational and strategic perspectives are identified through literature reviews, industrial case studies, interviews, workshops and controlled experiments. These are translated into criteria for a decision support, structured through the Feasibility, Suitability, Viability (FSV) framework, which distinguishes whether AM can be used from whether it should be. To operationalise the framework, two methods are proposed, each implemented as a working prototype and evaluated in controlled experiments with academic and industrial participants. The evaluation showed positive results for both methods in terms of usefulness and usability, and identified where each needs further development.

The contribution is to both science and practice. To science, design for additive manufacturing (DfAM) is extended from how to design for AM to whether and when to use it. To practice, two evaluated methods with working prototypes are offered, moving the decision from a late, intuitive judgement to an early, system-level assessment.

Digital Sustainability Implementation Package (DSIP)

VINNOVA, 2021-03-01 -- 2023-03-01.

VINNOVA (2020-04163), 2021-03-01 -- 2023-03-01.

Material efficient supply chains through decentralised Additive Manufacturing for the Swedish export industry

VINNOVA (2023-02499), 2023-10-19 -- 2024-05-31.

Demonstration of Infrastructure for Digitalization enabling industrialization of Additive Manufacturing (DiDAM)

VINNOVA, 2020-02-20 -- 2023-02-20.

VINNOVA (2019-05591), 2020-02-20 -- 2023-02-20.

Subject Categories (SSIF 2025)

Production Engineering, Human Work Science and Ergonomics

Other Engineering and Technologies

Driving Forces

Sustainable development

Innovation and entrepreneurship

Areas of Advance

Production

Infrastructure

Additive Manufacturing at Chalmers

DOI

10.63959/chalmers.dt/5982

ISBN

978-91-8103-525-4

Doktorsavhandlingar vid Chalmers tekniska högskola. Ny serie: 5982

Publisher

Chalmers

VDL

Online

Opponent: Katja Holtta-Otto

More information

Latest update

11/17/2026